That Fit Friend is supported by its readers. I [Jake] run this site myself and buy the gear reviewed. If you purchase through my site, I may earn commissions on sales. Read more here!
On has built a steady following in both the fitness and lifestyle spaces, but their naming of models and signature CloudTec midsoles can lead to confusion. Most of the comments that I receive on my On YouTube videos reflect this, too. Two models that gym-goers and casual wearers constantly cross-shop are the On Cloud X 5 and the On Cloud 6.
While they look like siblings at a glance, their design philosophies, structural support, and underfoot mechanics serve entirely different training and daily wear contexts. The On Cloud X 5 is engineered as a gym-first cross-training shoe that can flex into casual wear, whereas the On Cloud 6 is a lifestyle shoe built primarily for all-day comfort and walking.
And you might be thinking, “They can’t be that different; I can just use them interchangeably.” Sure, you can always do that, but I suggest using the right tools for the job. Plus, if you get the right shoe for your needs, then your investment will last longer.
Because both shoes sit at premium price points, buying the wrong pair for your training style can lead to rapid breakdown and wasted cash. Here are their head-to-head differences across lifting, cross-training, short runs, and daily comfort.
Performance Quick Hits
- Better for Heavy Lifting: On Cloud X 5. Its firmer, re-tuned CloudTec midsole provides significantly more rigidity and stability under barbell loads (sweet spot up to 275 lbs). The Cloud 6’s softer pods collapse and lack lateral stability beyond 135–185 lbs.
- Food for Thought: The Cloud X 5 won’t feel as stable as something like a Dropset 4 and Metcon 10, so grab those if you’re pushing 315+ lbs, but for beginners and intermediates, the Cloud X 5 should work just fine.
- Better for Cross-Training & Metcons: On Cloud X 5. The Cloud X 5 features reinforced midfoot overlays and structured heel padding to prevent foot spill during dynamic movements. The Cloud 6 has a relaxed, lax upper that allows excessive spillover during lateral drills.
- Food for Thought: If you’re purely focused on HIIT and need something for plyo, lateral cuts, and higher intensity classes, then you may want to explore other HIIT shoes that have better upper reinforcement.
- Better for Short Running Bouts: On Cloud X 5. It’s built with a more responsive midsole and durable tread geometry that handles 400m repeats up to 2–3 mile runs. Using the Cloud 6 for running will blow through the shoe’s softer materials and structure far too quickly, especially the midsole.
- Food for Thought: If you’re into HYROX-focused training and want something more dialed for short runs and hybrid workouts, I’d also look into the Adidas Adizero Dropset Pro.
- Better for Daily Wear & Commuting: Tie (use-case dependent). The Cloud 6 wins for pure slip-on convenience, a plush, softer step-in feel, and an easy-to-clean upper for messy weather. The Cloud X 5 is better if you prefer a firmer, more supportive platform with prominent arch support and plan to train in your shoes at all.
On Cloud 6
On Cloud X 5
Sizing and Fit Comparison
About My Feet: I have a normal arch/instep and my feet come in at an E/EE width. The length of my left and right foot are consistent with one another, and I size as a true US 10 for most companies’ sizing charts.
My Sizing Advice: Go true to size. Both the On Cloud X 5 and Cloud 6 fit true to size in overall length for standard foot anatomies. You should be safe to order the size you wear across other mainstream athletic footwear.
- Narrow to Standard (D-Width) Feet: Both shoes will fit true to size. The Cloud X 5 will feel more form-fitting and snug through the midfoot, while the Cloud 6 will feel slightly more relaxed and airy.
- Higher Insteps: The Cloud 6 is more accommodating for high insteps because its upper and midfoot lacing are significantly more relaxed, whereas the Cloud X 5’s rigid midfoot overlays can cause top-of-foot pressure.
- Arch Sensitivity: The Cloud X 5 features noticeable medial arch structure and a contoured insole that actively hugs the inside of your foot. If you dislike arch support or have completely flat feet, the Cloud 6 offers a much less intrusive feel.
- Wide Feet (2E+ Width): If you have wider feet, stick true to size in length, but note that the Cloud X 5’s tapered forefoot may feel snug on lateral toes, whereas the Cloud 6’s softer upper will stretch with less friction.
Buy the On Cloud X 5 If:
- You want one shoe primarily for the gym that can handle HIIT classes, light-to-moderate lifting (under 275 lbs), and short treadmill runs.
- You need a training shoe that transitions smoothly into casual errands after your workout.
- You prefer a firmer, more stable underfoot feel with prominent medial arch support.
On Cloud X 5
$160
Pros
- Better Sole Flexibility (than prior models)
- Strong Breathability
- Good for Arch Support Lovers
Cons
- Stability Can Be So-So
- Arch Can Be A Lot (for wider/flatter feet)
- Midfoot Security Could Be Better
Best For
- General Strength Workouts
- Circuit Training
- Classes and HIIT
- Interval Runs & Short Runs (up to 3 mi)
- Walking
Specs
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 8mm |
| Weight | 10.15 oz (size 10) |
| Width | Medium |
| Lifting Threshold | ~275 lbs |
| Run Distance Threshold | 3 mi (tested at one time) |
ALTERNATIVES
Buy the On Cloud 6 If:
- You are looking strictly for an all-day lifestyle, commuting, or walking shoe that has a moderately compressive midsole.
- You prioritize an easy slip-on-and-off design for travel, airport days, and casual outings.
- You want an upper that is easy to wipe clean and accommodates higher insteps without tight overlays.
On Cloud 6
$160
Pros
- Picks up fewer rocks
- Lightweight construction
- More spacious fit
Cons
- Midsole durability
- Narrow feet may find too loose
- Still picks up some rocks
Best For
- Casual Wear
- Walking
- Traveling
Specs
| Heel-to-Toe Drop | 8mm |
| Weight | 10.05 oz (size 10) |
| Width | Medium/Wide(r) |
| Lifting Threshold | <185 lbs |
| Run Distance Threshold | <1-2 miles |
Construction Differences
Upper
The On Cloud X 5 utilizes a dual-material upper with an airy mesh/knit forefoot paired with rigid, structured synthetic overlays across the medial and lateral midfoot for lateral lockdown. The heel collar features denser padding to secure the rearfoot.
The On Cloud 6 uses a softer, more uniform lifestyle mesh that is lighter and more pliable, designed with a slip-on feel that makes sliding the shoe on effortless. Its outer layering is also easier to wipe down and maintain against outdoor dirt compared to the absorbent knit of the X 5.
Midsole
The On Cloud X 5 features a firmer, denser CloudTec foam compound with an 8mm drop that resists heavy compression, providing a rigid and stable platform for gym training.
The On Cloud 6 uses a noticeably softer, plusher CloudTec compound that compresses easily underfoot to maximize casual walking cushion and comfort. Be careful with the Cloud 6 midsole on concrete, it’s pretty easy to scuff the edges of it.
Outsole
Both models incorporate On’s signature CloudTec pod channels with targeted rubber tread on high-wear heel and forefoot strike zones, but the Cloud X 5’s outsole is designed to withstand gym floor abrasion and sled drags, whereas the Cloud 6 is tuned purely for pavement, indoor walking, and dry daily use.
Final Remarks: Which Model Should You Choose?
At the end of the day, choosing between the On Cloud X 5 and the On Cloud 6 comes down to where you spend the majority of your time.
If your goal is to train in the gym, take workout classes, and hit short cardio intervals—while still having a shoe you can rock casually—the On Cloud X 5 is the clear choice. It provides the necessary midfoot lockdown, heel containment, and foam density that fitness requires.
However, if you have zero intention of lifting or doing metcons and simply want an ultra-comfortable, stylish lifestyle shoe for daily errands, work shifts, and travel, the On Cloud 6 is the superior daily driver.
If you have additional questions about how the On Cloud X 5 or On Cloud 6 fit, or which model matches your weekly routine, drop a comment below!
Add a Comment